In 1976, workers at Lucas Aerospace plants around the UK launched their pioneering Alternative Workers Plan. Faced with threats to their jobs, the workers responded with a visionary, positive plan that challenged economic orthodoxy. They proposed 150 detailed ideas for socially useful products the company could make, such as heat pumps, wind turbines and kidney machines, instead of fighter jet parts. The Lucas Plan became world-famous and has continued to inspire people up to the present. An excellent new video provides a good introduction to the plan and the issues it raised
The 50th anniversary of the Lucas plan was celebrated at a major conference in Manchester in November, under the banner ‘an idea whose time must come’. David King, one of the event organisers, produced an overview blog saying that we now need new bigger bolder plans for the future. ‘Like the Lucas Aerospace workers, we need to go back to the real material and social roots of the problem: are we producing to satisfy people’s real needs or for profit? We need a new Lucas Plan that provides mutually compatible technological and social answers to that question’.
The conference heard from some of the surviving Lucas shop stewards and from the new wave of activist inspired by the original plan- looking at what might be done now. The current situation is a bit different to that in the 1970s. Then the Labour government, under Harold Wilson, was moving away from defence spending, not as now, toward more of it - thanks to fears about what Putin might do next. But the basic funding idea behind the Lucas workers plan is still relevant. In effect it called for radical shift from state funding of defence equipment production to funding by the local state and via the public sector generally for socially needed products and systems - for schools, hospitals, care homes, council estates and so on, as part of a not-for-profit social market system. Bold stuff.
However, although, post-privatisation, the UK is now a very long way from that (the public versus private sector spit was almost 50/50 in the 1970s), the conference heard about some contemporary grass roots initiatives heading, if only tentatively, in this direction, in a range of sectors, including food, care, education and housing, as well as energy. For example, on the latter, there was good contribution on what needed to be done in relation to the North Sea - with new drilling and continued jobs from that being a current very lively issue. Jobs are obviously important, but there isn’t much oil and gas left in the North Sea and there is a strong strategic and environmental case for leaving it there.
As David King had said in a pre-conference comment, food was seen as a good new area to look at since alternative and traditional non-industrial systems can meet needs sustainably. The food workshop heard from the Community Supported Agriculture Network about some impressive local initiatives and also with from a ‘right to grow’ campaigner. And linking it all up, radical stalwart Charlie Clutterbuck noted that, although the Lucas plan was partly about ‘turning swords into ploughshares’, in fact we had to be careful about what sort of ploughshares - industrial scale farming uses huge machines that damage the soil. And, continuing the food analogy, in the final plenary session, it was pointed out that what was being asked for was not just a bigger slice of the cake, or even the ownership of the bakery, but better bread.
It was a full day with a range of other workshop sessions, including on AI, local planning, defence conversion and climate change. A lot of big difficult issues. But in her comments in the plenary session, Hilary Wainwright, co-author (with myself) of a celebrated book on the original plan, said what stood out from the Lucas plan was that, however grim the situation, something can always be done. She was right. The status quo can and, if you are a radical, should always be challenged. And the conference arguably showed that, while the Lucas plan had been well ahead of its time technologically, as well as politically, for example pushing ideas for alternative energy systems that have only recently started to be fully accepted, now it was time take on wider area of engagement.
What might that mean in practice? In a pre-conference commentary, David King had said we needed to ‘encourage the drawing together of many small scale and localised projects into a real economy providing basic needs that can undermine dependence upon the industrial market’.
That sounds challenging, but possible. Though, from a radical perspective, it still will no doubt come down to economic and political power - who has it and how to challenge them. The Lucas workers had essentially tried to challenge and change the managements plan, and they failed. The company was not willing to yield the right to manage. But, as ever, trade union activists and grass roots radicals still continue to challenge the status quo, for example on climate issues. And as new technologies and new possibilities emerge, that is surely a good thing.
*The plenary and workshop sessions were recorded and should be available soon on the New Lucas Plan website.
Afterword: What Chat GPT AI thinks about the Lucas Plans
‘It was a concrete experiment in the potential for workers to challenge managerial authority and redirect industrial capacity towards socially determined objectives. Its immediate proposals could have been implemented without abolishing capitalism, but its more ambitious implications called into question the distribution of power within capitalist production’. And in the context of the wider plan for industrial democracy and tripartite corporate planning that Tony Benn was trying to develop, the Lucas Plan, the AI said ‘was not an unrealistic attempt to abolish markets through factory-level decision-making. It was a possible component of a broader alternative industrial strategy-one that Britain's Labour government began to construct but never fully implemented’. Maybe AI isn’t always reactionary!
Comments
Post a Comment